Immigration and Islam

October 2026: I am starting a new collection. With considerable trepidation.

It is hard to talk about some ideas (such as what is Islam like?) without people accusing you of being prejudiced.

I have to say, I am concerned at what is happening to my country, and immigration and islam are causing changes that are making me ask questions about the very nature of our nation.

I have always had a positive attitude towards people of all religions. To be more precise, I love all people. And I still do. Asking questions doesn’t change that.

—

This collection may grow over the coming weeks, but for now, I am just collecting some videos and interviews that have been opening up the discussion around immigration and islam so that I can share them with some friends.

—

Immigration – I am not against people moving to our country and becoming part of our nation. However, I am concerned about the increasing proportion of people in the UK who would like to live in an islamic culture/nation.

Here is an 11 minute analysis by Konstantin Kisin, of the Triggernometry channel. It’s not immigration itself that is the problem, but immigration of people whose culture is incompatible with ours.

What do you know about the core beliefs of Islam?

I have recently learnt that islam, as revealed in the Qu’ran, is not a religion that will live quietly alongside other religions. I am able to hear this, think about it, seek to learn more and still love my muslim friends and neighbours.

Here is a 20 minute overview of the history of Islam and it’s incompatibility with western culture.

0:44 βš”οΈ Muhammad, War & Slavery
3:25 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ Jefferson, Barbary Pirates & Islam
4:24 β˜ͺ️ Moderate vs Fundamentalist Muslims
7:24 πŸ›οΈ Christian Nations Becoming Muslim
7:53 πŸ“œ The Origins of Muhammad
10:08 πŸ‘οΈ The Cave Revelation
12:08 πŸ•Œ Medina, Politics & Power
14:51 ✑️ The Jews of Medina
16:01 🌍 Immigration, Expansion & Dawa
18:15 βš–οΈ Sharia, Halal & Haram
19:06 ✝️ Christianity vs Islam
20:34 πŸ“– Quran, Hadith & Islamic Law
21:34 βš”οΈ Sunni vs Shia Explained
22:55 ☒️ Iran, the Mahdi & End Times

My reflections on the above:

Mr Federer says most muslims are moderate. Certainly I would describe all the muslims I have known as moderate. This includes neighbours and friends who I count as upstanding members of our community.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali – perspective of a Somali muslim

October 2026: This is a long interview. Covers many topics.

Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a Somali-born author, former Dutch politician and prominent critic of Islamism. Discusses the riots in France, the influence of the Muslim Brotherhood, and what she believes is the failure of Western governments to maintain law and order.

Drawing on her extraordinary journey from Somalia to Europe, Hirsi Ali also discusses the differences between Western societies and the countries from which many asylum seekers originate.

Some notes:

France – Riots over the states of schools? A broken social contract – the government’s role is to provide law and order. Protests hijacked by far-left – antifa and communist. And muslim groups in France that are anti-state, such as Muslim Brotherhood. Palestinian flags, communist. Anti-nation state comments. How is all this connected to school protests? Organised groups are allowed to rampage unchecked.

French have state of emergency laws which were instigated after a spate of attacks a few years ago. Why are they not exercising these powers?

Islamophobia – legislation to stop criticism of islam.

Rioters – no clear political demands? Just wanting to loot. Much social science literature suggests rioting and looting is thrilling and entertaining. The most important role of government is to maintain domestic order and protect from external threat. Why are they not doing that, for several years now? A violation of the social contract.

Why France? Why not in UK? There has been some rioting in UK. Some commentators says its only a matter of time. Same ingredients – organised far left; huge presence of muslim brotherhood and organised groups; disaffection among young men towards government; a government with similar stance to French government.

Marine Le Pen – said law-abiding muslim citizens can stay in the country. Of course! But is the government going to dismantle the groups that say they want to take down the country’s structures and replace it with something else?

Ayaan’s story. Arrived in 1992. Immediately astonished by the threshold of violence. Astonished at how peaceful it was – almost no violence tolerated in public. But where she came from there was violence at home, at school, in the street, from gangs, sexual violence. e.g. as a teenager witnessed a lynching of someone accused of being a thief. And that was before wars – massacres on the basis of clan. Take large numbers of men from that setting, without addressing their trauma – they will continue in that way of solving problems. e.g. Somalia mother said to son you must beat up that other pupil who called you names. Teacher and mother sitting across the table and not being able to understand each other.

1951 Geneva convention on asylum was not designed for thousands of people coming from Africa and middle east. Asylum system was for a specific time in a specific place – European wars. From similar culture. Small numbers of people, who assimilated quickly.

Ayaan’s story – sought asylum on basis of escaping arranged marriage. Was advised that she would not get asylum on that basis. Geneva convention was explained to her. So reconfigured her story to one that the government wanted. Millions of people are doing this. It’s one big scam. It is an outdated system. It should be nationalised – each country should decide its own asylum processes and decisions.

Every country should decide who it wants to admit – immigration is good.

Poor countries can not be made stable or rich when they loose people to immigration.

Ayaan has benefited from asylum. Isn’t it unfair for you to ‘draw up the ladder’. They’ve come from terrible situations and would be persecuted.

I am compelled to speak out because I benefitted. The only way to respond is to give everything you have in return. Become a loyal citizen – abide by the law, learn the language, do not rely on welfare. It is the job of the government to ask how many of people coming in are capable of that or even want to do that.

Bigger question. What do rich countries do for poor countries? It’s fraudulent to let citizens of poor countries believe that if they come to rich countries all their problems will be solved. And it’s fraudulent not to ask the citizens of the host countries if they want all these people from these traumatic situations to be dumped here, largely in working class areas. They are already having a hard time making ends meet and this adds extra pressure.

Q – The left deny that these immigrants are any different from us. All men commit sexual violence. There is no difference in crime rates.

Ayaan – Note, it’s not just illegal immigrants. All migrants are different. No one ever discusses those from Europe who came here in 1940s – 1960s. The immigration discussion is really a euphemism for muslim immigrants. The largest number of muslims do have problems assimilating into the host society and we have not addressed this for many decades.

Q – how do immigrants from third world countries view the countries?

Ayaan – wow I was not afraid of the state, of men, of random violence. But it depends on who the immigrants are communicating with. The first Somalians I met were very negative about many aspects of the situation they were in. I chose to assimilate into dutch society. Young men see social media – pornography, movies. Relatives tell them come here, get everything for free, they are infidels, the women are for the taking. They see young men who have done similar things and go unpunished or very light sentences for very serious crimes.

Formal doctrinal Islam sees three kinds of women. (1) Modest women – hijab, stay at home, obey fathers, husband; (2) Women whom your right hand owns (servants) – men who own them or for whom they work for can take advantage of them as they please; (3) All other women are harlots, prostitutes. Women for the taking – they are PREY – it is your right.

Resentment of the countries of the west? Anyone coming from Somalia, Syria, Afghanistan, Yemen will have a relative who facilitates their arrival here. They prime you into what to expect. The people bringing you in can prepare you by explaining there is a reason this country is doing well and we don’t need to resent it, we can become like them! Or you could be steered into the mosque and told the society that has just accepted you are infidels (kafir), don’t assimilate with them, take what you can, and for the sake of All’ah engage in jihad. The infrastructure that they have assembled for this indoctrination is not being dismantled. Coming from Syria you barely know anything about islam and then in Birmingham you learn about islam, you are radicalised and join the jihad.

Its not that people want to take the negative side of their culture. They are just living as they had learned to live where they came from. Broken culture there – broken culture here.

There is no infrastructure to shape them into law-abiding citizens. Yet we allow organisations like the muslim brotherhood to build mosques, schools, infrastructure that turns them away from western culture. Politicians are funding this, taking tax payer money to destroy the countries they are representing.

[44:14] Enlightenment from material progress. Can Somalia become a liberal, enlightened country? Can it be fixed if exposed to technology, health care, material benefits etc.

Ayaan – I used to think that. If there is less to fight about and worry about all will be well. But the enlightenment picture is just one view point on human nature. If you grow up a muslim – define a good muslim as engaging in jihad and being concerned the world for islam. Material comforts are not going to answer your purpose, meaning and spiritiuality.

I see enlightenment as the fruit of a particular Christian viewpoint. For example South Korea. Do the experiment the other way. Yes you can see how muslim societies develop. Its not ethnicity, it is comparing ideas – which set of ideas leads to a superior outcome.

What is the political influence of islam on the individual? The idea of islam itself – do it by force or gradually through the system? It has been tried by violence – terrorist activities. July 7; Manchester stadium;

Dawah is the long process.

Is Kemi Baddenock English? Not ethnically English. But is she a loyal British citizen. Ethnically Nigerian woman is not white english. But loyalty to British system is the key thing. Islam has the concept of ummah – the primary identity of being islam, regardless of their ethnicity.

[55] (three components of national identity)Ethnic identity or civic identity? Call all the white english to come back? Is it exclusionary? Is it about you and we don’t like you? It is a legitimate worry for English people to not become a minority on their own island! (Englishness)

More urgent and more important is allegiance. (Britishness) We have people who have citizenship in Britain whose allegiance does not lie with Britain. They openly say they want to transform Britain into something it is not.

A third layer – UK as a Christian nation (Religion).

Not finished taking notes yet. There is more discussion of the institutional dawah. Example of Turkey, Egypt.